Skip to main content

Section 1.4 Invitation to Overcome Challenges

Subsection 1.4.1 Growing through Persistance

Have you ever watched a baby learn a new skill, like walking, crawling, or even rolling over? The child does not master the skill on the first try, but they are determined. They fall down, perhaps bump their head, but they keep trying. They readjust what they are doing, figure out how to create momentum and balance, and finally succeed. Even then they may stumble, but they persist. In the process, they grow stronger and can apply these skills to later learning, like running, climbing the cabinets, and reaching the cookie jar.
Throughout our lives, we grow by challenging ourselves to move beyond our comfort zone. We learn to read and write, play games and sports, cook, make music, or create art. Our brains are muscles that develop as we attempt new challenges. The nature of mathematics involves struggling with a problem, trying different strategies, taking breaks but persisting, and learning from failed attempts. In the explorations of this section, you may find that some of the problems are easy, but others require looking at the problem in new ways and trying different strategies. Accept the challenge, try out different ideas, and don’t worry about making mistakes. Allow these attempts to enable growth and eventual success.

Exploration 1.4.1. Triangles on a Geoboard.

You may use tools that you remember from previous courses, such as the area formula for a triangle and the Pythagorean Theorem, as you complete this activity. We will explore why these formulas hold in Chapter 2.
(a)
In this exploration, we will work with a geoboard that has four rows and four columns of pins such as the one pictured below.
A grid with 16 dots arranged in four rows and four columns.
  1. Measuring along any row, we will assume that the horizontal distance between neighboring dots on a geoboard is one unit. What is the distance across the top of the geoboard from the leftmost pin to the rightmost pin?
  2. Similarly, the vertical distance between neighboring pins in any column will be one unit. Determine the area of the square whose vertices are the four outermost pins on this geoboard.
  3. Determine the shortest diagonal distance between two pins. In other words, what is the distance from the pin in the upper left corner to the pin in the second row and second column?
  4. What is the distance from the top left pin to the bottom right pin?
(b)
As we construct triangles and other shapes on our geoboard, note that each vertex must be one one of the sixteen pins.
  1. Construct a triangle with the smallest possible area. What is the area?
  2. Construct a triangle with the largest possible area. Then construct a second triangle with the same area that is not the same shape as the first. Record your sketches and compute this area.
    Interactive tool on Polypad by Amplify
     2 
    mathigon.org/polypad/embed/OADtl0auGfB1A
(c)
Construct triangles with an area different than any triangle you’ve already drawn. Counting the triangles you drew in Item 1, it is possible to create a total of eight triangles each with a different area. Be sure to record your sketches of the triangles and their areas for reference.
Interactive tool on Polypad by Amplify
 3 
mathigon.org/polypad/embed/OADtl0auGfB1A
Hint.
The possible areas are \(\frac{1}{2}, 1, \frac{3}{2}, 2, \frac{5}{2},3, \frac{7}{2}, 4, \frac{9}{2}\text{.}\)
(d)
Extension: If we use a 5x5-geoboard instead, what squares and what triangles are possible? Compute the areas. A virtual 5x5-GeoBoard is available at apps.mathlearningcenter.org/geoboard/
 4 
apps.mathlearningcenter.org/geoboard/
.

Subsection 1.4.2 Confronting the Challenge

To give you the experience of confronting the challenge and the exhilaration of conquering it, the answer to the last task in this exploration will not be provided here. Searching for solutions or examples will not help you grow mathematically. Instead, consider other ways in which you might attack the problem. Dare to try something new!
The above exploration starts off relatively easy. Once you understood how to create and measure shapes on the geoboard, you probably found triangles with areas of \(\frac{1}{2}, 1, \frac{3}{2}, 2, 3\text{,}\) and \(\frac{9}{2}\text{.}\) In fact, you might have found multiple triangles with these areas. Yet the remaining areas may seem impossible. If you are still in this situation, think about why these same six areas keep occurring. What do these triangles have in common? What other types of triangles exist on the GeoBoard?
As you find these new triangles, another question emerges: How does one compute the area of these triangles? To use the area formula, \(A=\frac{1}{2}bh\text{,}\) one usually uses the values of \(b\) and \(h\text{.}\) How does one find \(b\) and \(h\) with certainty? Or is it necessary to find the base and height of the triangle? Might there be other ways of finding the area in the current setting?
There are many lessons to be learned here that go beyond measuring area. Mathematics is not about doing fast calculations with provided formulas or following steps. Instead, it requires persistence, creative thinking, and exploring multiple strategies. Sometimes it is helpful to walk away from a problem for a little while and to return to it with a different perspective. It helps to share ideas with others even when you do not know where they will lead.
Did you discover a triangle that was not obvious? Did you figure out a way to compute the area of these triangles? Did you help others understand? Be proud of your discoveries and contributions. This is evidence that you, yes you, are a mathematician!
Each student brings their own individual strengths to the class. Some are great at remembering and applying formulas while others are great at drawing sketches. Some have a talent for recognizing patterns or building on others’ ideas while other students are adept at explaining results and connections. In fact, you may find yourself contributing in different ways on different activities. The important thing is to believe in yourself and be open to trying new things. Unfortunately, most people believe the myth that they can’t do math. They spend too much energy comparing themselves to others. Math is not about being perfect or fast. Instead, mathematics is about exploring, creating, experimenting, conjecturing, applying, and justifying.
If today was not your day to shine, perhaps you were hesitant to consider alternative approaches or to pursue your ideas. This particular topic might not have engaged you in the same way as it did others. Or maybe it was just an off day. There will be more opportunities to overcome challenges throughout this book. As long as you are open to learning and exploring your own ideas, your mathematical ability and confidence will grow. After all, the course has just started, and you are just adapting to this book and its style, your instructor, and your classmates. By the way, your brain may hurt a little as you confront and conquer mathematical challenges. Like every other muscle in your body, a little soreness means that you are growing in strength. Success comes from overcoming the struggle, from remembering and building on your accomplishments and missteps.

Subsection 1.4.3 A Geometric Tool and an Algebraic Tool

As we have noticed in this section, not all segments are horizontal or vertical. To determine the lengths of these slanted segments on a grid, the Pythagorean Theorem 2.5.2 will be helpful. The Pythagorean Theorem allows us to find the lengths of the sides of right triangles using the fact that \(a^2+b^2=c^2\) where \(c\) is the length of the hypotenuse and \(a\) and \(b\) are the lengths of the legs of the triangle. A more in-depth exploration of the Pythagorean Theorem will be pursued in Section 2.5.
Applying the Pythagorean Theorem requires facility with the algebraic operation of squaring and its inverse operation, the square root function. A review of how to work with squares and square roots is provided in A.4.1 in the Backmatter.

Exercises 1.4.4 Exercises

Skills and Recall

1.
Compute the following numbers if they exist.
  1. \(\displaystyle \sqrt{49}\)
  2. \(\displaystyle \sqrt{900}\)
  3. \(\displaystyle \sqrt{16-25}\)
  4. \(\displaystyle \sqrt{\frac{16}{25}}\)
  5. \(\displaystyle \sqrt{25-16}\)
  6. \(\displaystyle \sqrt{25}-\sqrt{16}\)
  7. \(\displaystyle \sqrt{123456789^2}\)
  8. \(\displaystyle \sqrt{0}\)
  9. \(\displaystyle \sqrt{3}\cdot\sqrt{3}\)
  10. \(\displaystyle \sqrt{2\cdot 2}\)
Hint.
One answer is not a real number.

Extending the Concepts

2. Properties of Squares and Square Roots.
Use algebra rules or experimentation to determine the following. Your answers should contain variables. A review of square roots may be found in Subsubsection A.4.1
  1. Let \(x\) be any nonnegative number. What is \(\sqrt{x\cdot x}\text{?}\)
  2. Let \(x\) be any nonnegative number. What is \(\sqrt{x}\cdot\sqrt{x}\text{?}\)
  3. Let \(x\) be any nonnegative number. What is \((\sqrt{x})^2\text{?}\)
  4. Let \(x\) be any nonnegative number. What is \(\sqrt{x^2}\text{?}\)
  5. Let \(x\) be any negative number. Is \(\sqrt{x^2}=x\text{?}\) Explain.
  6. Let \(x\) be any negative number. Is \((\sqrt{x})^2=x\text{?}\) Explain.
  7. Is \(x^2+y^2=(x+y)^2\text{?}\) To support your answer, choose a nonzero number \(x\) and a nonzero number \(y\text{,}\) substitute your values into the equation, and carefully evaluate both sides.
  8. Is \(\sqrt{x^2+y^2}=x+y\text{?}\) Explain.

Writing Prompts

3. Geoboard Experience.
Discuss the emotions that you experienced as you were working on this activity. Did you encounter moments when you felt stuck? How long did that last? What helped you persist through the process? Were you able to get unstuck without being told answers? How did that make you feel? Discussion of other emotional stages of this activity is allowed provided that you focus on the emotions associated with the struggle and challenge of conquering a mathematical task.
If this particular activity did not challenge you as much as an earlier one, then your instructor may give you permission to discuss one of those instead.
4. Growing via Challenges.
Reflect on a time when you had to struggle to learn how to do something (not necessarily mathematics), but where you eventually succeeded. Describe the event, why and how you struggled, what helped you persist, and how you grew. Did you feel differently about this success compared to successfully completing routine tasks? Can this experience help you as you tackle tough questions in this course?